CHAPTER 12 EDUCATION AND RELIGION 41099.jpg animism church civil religion credentialism cult cultural capital denomination ecclesia education hidden curriculum profane religion sacred sect secularization tracking I. AN OVERVIEW OF EDUCATION AND RELIGION: A. Education and religion are powerful and influential institutions that impart values, beliefs, and knowledge considered essential to the social reproduction of individual personalities and entire cultures. B. Education and religion are socializing institutions: early socialization primarily takes place in families and friendship networks; later socialization occurs in more formalized organizations created for the purposes of education and religion. STOP: Explain why education and religion are powerful and influential forces in contemporary society. II. SOCIOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES ON EDUCATION A. Functionalists view education as one of the most important components of society. The National Center for educational Statistics, a division of the U.S. government collects and publishes reports on the condition of education, including students, faculty and teaching staff, school expenditures, and other useful compilations of data. http://www.ed.gov/nces/index.html http://www.ed.gov/nces/index.html 1. Education serves five major manifest functions open, stated, and intended goals or consequences of activities within an organization or institution: a. Socialization b. Transmission of culture c. Social control d. Social placement e. Change and innovation 2. Education has at least three latent functions -- hidden, unstated, and sometimes-unintended consequences of activities within an organization or institution: 24001 a. Restricting some activities; b. Matchmaking and production of social networks; and c. Creation of a generation gap. B. According to conflict theorists, schools perpetuate class, race, ethnic, and gender inequalities as some groups seek to maintain their privileged position at the expense of others. 1. Reproduction of Class: education is a vehicle for reproducing existing class relationships. a. According to Pierre Bourdieu, children have less chance of academic success when they lack cultural capital -- social assets that include values, beliefs, attitudes, and competencies in language and culture. b. Children from middle and upper-income families are endowed with more cultural capital than children from working-class and poverty-level families. c. Class reproduction also occurs through standardized tests, ability grouping, and tracking the assignment of students to specific courses and educational programs based on their test scores, previous grades, or both. STOP: Describe conflict perspectives on education and note how they differ from a functionalist perspective. II. SOCIOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES ON EDUCATION B. According to conflict theorists, schools perpetuate class, race, ethnic, and gender inequalities as some groups seek to maintain their privileged position at the expense of others. 2. The hidden curriculum is the transmission of cultural values and attitudes, such as conformity and obedience to authority, through implied demands found in rules, routines, and regulations of schools. 24255 a. Lower-class students may be disqualified from higher education and the credentials needed in a society that emphasizes credentialism a process of social selection in which class advantage and social status are linked to the possession of academic qualification. b. Credentialism is closely related to meritocracy: persons who acquire the appropriate credentials for a job are assumed to have gained the position through what they know. c. Gender bias is embedded in both the formal and the hidden curricula of schools; the educational opportunities of U.S. females are not equal to those of males in their social class. 3. Unequal funding is a source of inequality in education. a. Most educational funds are derived from local property taxes and state legislative appropriations. b. Children living in affluent suburbs often attend relatively new schools and have access to the latest equipment which students in central city schools and poverty-ridden rural areas do not have. c. A voucher system would allow students and their families to spend a specified sum of government money to purchase education at the school of their choice. B. According to conflict theorists, schools perpetuate class, race, ethnic, and gender inequalities as some groups seek to maintain their privileged position at the expense of others. 4. Segregated and Resegregated Schools a. Racially segregated schools often have low retention rates, students with below-grade level reading skills, high teacher-student ratios, less-qualified teachers, and low teacher expectations 45035 b. Racial segregation is increasing in some U.S. schools, and efforts to bring about desegregation or integration have failed in many school districts. c. African American and white achievement differences increase with every year of schooling; thus, schools may reinforce, rather than eliminate, the disadvantages of race and class. 41319 5. Class, Race, and Social Reproduction in Higher Education The American Association of University Women regularly reports about gender and education. http://www.aauw.org http://www.aauw.org a. Access to colleges and universities are determined not only by a person's prior academic record but also by the ability to pay. VIDEO: College costs continue to rise steeply despite low inflation in general. V15 b. Enrollment of low-income students in higher education has dropped since the 1980s as a result of declining scholarship funds and of many students having to hold a full- or part-time job to finance their education. C. Interactionist Perspective on Education 1. Education and the Self-Fulfilling Prophecy a. For some students, schooling may become a self-fulfilling prophecy an unsubstantiated belief or prediction that results in behavior which makes the originally false belief come true. b. If a teacher (as a result of stereotypes based on the relationship between IQ and race) believes that some students of color are less capable of learning, that teacher (sometimes without even realizing it) may treat them as if they were incapable of learning. 2. Education and Labeling Dropping Out of School is one of the persistent problems plagues education in America today. See the site of the National Dropout Prevention Center for information on research and programs for dropout prevention. http://www.dropoutprevention.org http://www.dropoutprevention.org a. IQ testing has resulted in labeling of students (e.g., African American and Mexican American children have been placed in special education classes on the basis of IQ scores when they could not understand the tests). b. A self-fulfilling prophecy also can result from labeling students as gifted. When some students are labeled as better than others, they may achieve at a higher level because of the label, or they may face discrimination from others (e.g., Asian Americans as superintelligent). c. Some analysts suggest that girls receive subtle cues from adults that lead them to attribute success to effort while boys learn to attribute success to their intelligence and ability. Conversely, girls attribute failure to lack of ability while boys attribute failure to lack of effort. STOP: Discuss interactionist perspectives on education, and describe the significance of the self-fulfilling prophecy and labeling on educational achievement. III. RELIGION IN GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE A. Religion and the Meaning of Life Rl001319 1. Religion is a system of beliefs, symbols, and rituals, based on some sacred or supernatural realm, that guides human behavior, gives meaning to life, and unites believers into a community. RL000562 2. Religion seeks to answer important questions such as why we exist, why people suffer and die, and what happens when we die. Ls019831 3. Sacred and Profane Rl001199 a. According to Emile Durkheim, sacred refers to those aspects of life that are extraordinary or supernatural; those things that are set apart as "holy." b. Those things people do not set apart as sacred are referred to as profane, the everyday, secular or "worldly," aspects of life. 4. In addition to beliefs, religion also is comprised of symbols and rituals -- symbolic actions that represent religious meanings that range from songs and prayers to offerings and sacrifices. 32082 5. Religions have been classified into four main categories based on their dominant belief: a. Simple supernaturalism is the belief that supernatural forces affect people's lives either positively or negatively. b. Animism is the belief that plants, animals, or other elements of the natural world are endowed with spirits or life forces having an impact on events in society. c. Theism is a belief in one or more god or gods. (1) Monotheism is a belief in a single, supreme being or god who is responsible for significant events such as the creation of the world. Examples include: Christianity and Judaism. (2) Polytheism is a belief in more than one god. Examples include Hinduism and Shinto. d. Transcendent idealism is a belief in sacred principles of thought and conduct, such as truth, justice, life, and tolerance for others. An example is Buddhism. STOP: List and discuss the four categories of religion. III. RELIGION IN GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE B. Religion and Scientific Explanation 1. During the Industrial Revolution, rapid growth in scientific and technological knowledge gave rise to the idea that science ultimately would answer questions that previously had been in the realm of religion. 2. Many scholars believed that scientific knowledge would result in secularization -- the process by which religious beliefs, practices, and institutions lose their significance in sectors of society and culture -- but others point out a resurgence of religious beliefs and an unprecedented development of alternative religions in recent years. IV. SOCIOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES ON RELIGION A. Functionalist Perspectives on Religion 60250 1. According to Emile Durkheim, the central feature of all religions is the presence of sacred beliefs and rituals that bind people together in a collectivity. 2. Religion has three important functions in any society: a. providing meaning and purpose to life; b. promoting social cohesion and a sense of belonging; and c. providing social control and support for the government. 3. Civil religion is the set of beliefs, rituals, and symbols that make sacred the values of the society and place the nation in the context of the ultimate system of meaning. B. Conflict Perspectives on Religion 1. According to Karl Marx, the capitalist class uses religious ideology as a tool of domination to mislead the workers about their true interests; thus, religion is the "opiate of the people." 2. By contrast, Max Weber argued that religion could be a catalyst to produce social change. a. In The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Weber linked the teachings of John Calvin with the growth of capitalism. b. Calvin emphasized predestination -- the belief that all people are divided into two groups, the saved and the damned, and only God knows who will go to heaven (the elect) and who will go to hell, even before they are born. c. Because people cannot know whether they will be saved, they look for signs that they are among the elect. As a result, people work hard, save their money and do not spend it on worldly frivolity; instead, they reinvest it in their land, equipment, and labor. d. As people worked ever harder to prove their religious piety, structural conditions became right in Europe for the industrial revolution, free markets, and the commercialization of the economy, which worked hand-in-hand with their religious teachings. C. Interactionist Perspectives on Religion 32082 1. For many people, religion serves as a reference group to help them define themselves. Religious symbols, for example, have a meaning to large bodies of people (e.g., the Star of David for Jews; the crescent moon and star for Muslims; and the cross for Christians). 2. Her Religion and His Religion. All people do not interpret religion in the same way. Women and men may belong to the same religions, but their individual religion will not necessarily be a carbon copy of the group's entire system of beliefs. V. TYPES OF RELIGIOUS ORGANIZATION A. Some countries have an official or state religion known as an ecclesia a religious organization that is so integrated into the dominant culture that it claims as its membership all members of a society. Examples include: the Anglican Church (the official Church of England), the Lutheran Church in Sweden and Denmark, the Catholic Church in Spain, and Islam in Iran and Pakistan. B. The Church-Sect Typology. 1. A church is a large, bureaucratically-organized religious organization that tends to seek accommodation with the larger society in order to maintain some degree of control over it. 2. Mid-way between the church and the sect is a denomination: a large, organized religion characterized by accommodation to society but frequently lacking in ability or intention to dominate society. 3. A sect is a relatively small religious group that has broken away from another religious organization to renew what it views as the original version of the faith. C. A cult is a religious group with practices and teachings outside the dominant cultural and religious traditions of a society 1. Some major religions (including Judaism, Islam, and Christianity) and some denominations (such as the Mormons) started as cults. 2. Cult leadership is based on charismatic characteristics of the individual, including an unusual ability to form attachments with others. STOP: Distinguish between the different types of religious organizations and note why a religious group may move from one category to another over time. VI. TRENDS IN RELIGION IN THE UNITED STATES A. The rise of a new fundamentalism has occurred at the same time that a number of mainline denominations have been losing membership. VIDEO: One of the fastest growing religions in America is Islam. V11 B. Some members of the political elite in Washington have vowed to bring religion "back" into schools and public life. Academic Info Religion maintains a site which serves as a reference to numerous Internet resources on religion. It includes links to sites on diverse religious faiths, religious studies programs, directories of religion in the U.S., new religious movements, and special topics such as women and religion. http://www.academicinfo.net/religionindex.html http://www.academicinfo.net/religionindex.html VII. EDUCATION AND RELIGION IN THE FUTURE A. Education will remain an important social institution in the future. Also remaining, however, will be the controversies over what should be taught and how to raise levels of academic achievement in the United States. B. Religious organizations will continue to be important in the lives of many people; however, the influence of religious beliefs and values will be felt even by those who claim no religious beliefs of their own. C. In other nations, the rise of religious nationalism has led to the blending of strongly held religious and political beliefs. D. In the United States, the influence of religion will be evident in ongoing battles over school prayer, abortion, gay rights, and women's issues, among others. On some fronts, religion may unify people; on others, it may contribute to confrontations among individuals and groups. 20 _____is the social institution responsible for the systematic transmission of knowledge, skills, and cultural values within a formally organized structure. Religion Mass media The government Education dEducation is the social institution responsible for the systematic transmission of knowledge, skills, and cultural values within a formally organized structure. (p. 340) Which of the following is a manifest function of education? Creation of a generation gap Restricting some activities Matchmaking and production of social networks Social control dWhich of the following is a manifest function of education? social control (p. 342) _____functions are hidden, unstated, and sometimes unintended consequences of activities within an organization or institution. Manifest Dormant Latent Covert cLatent functions are hidden, unstated, and sometimes unintended consequences of activities within an organization or institution. (p. 343) Sociologist_____has suggested that students come to school with differing amounts of cultural capital. Emile Durkheim Pierre Bourdieu Jeannie Oakes Clifford Geertz bSociologist Pierre Bourdieu has suggested that students come to school with differing amounts of cultural capital. (p. 344) The assignment of students to specific courses and educational programs based on their test scores, previous grades, or both is known as: tracking. the hidden curriculum. equitable assessment. class reproduction. aThe assignment of students to specific course and educational programs based on their tests scores, previous grades, or both is known as tracking. (p. 343) According to the_____perspective, the hidden curriculum affects working-class and poverty-level students more than it does students from middle- and upper-income families. functionalist conflict interactionist feminist bAccording to the conflict perspective, the hidden curriculum affects working-class and poverty-level students more than it does students from middle- and upper-income families. (p. 344) According to the text, schools for students from elite families: work to develop students' analytical powers and critical thinking skills. focus on creative activities in which students express their own ideas. have decreased in number during the past decade. have lowered their tuition in recent years in order to increase minority enrollment. aAccording to the text, schools for students from elite families work to develop students' analytical powers and critical thinking skills. (p. 344) Most educational funds are derived from: the federal government. private resources. local property taxes and state legislative appropriations. students' tuition and fees. cMost educational funds are derived from local property taxes and state legislative appropriations. (p. 345) Which of the following statements regarding higher education is true? The enrollment of low-income students has increased since the 1980s. There has been an increase in scholarship funds over the past decade. The ability to pay for a college education reproduces the class system. African American enrollment as a percentage of total college attendance has increased over the past two decades. cWhich of the following statements regarding higher education is true? The ability to pay for a college education reproduces the class system. (p. 349) A teacher who believes (as a result of stereotypes based on the relationship between IQ and race) that some students of color are less capable of learning and treats them accordingly is an example of: a self-fulfilling prophecy. the labeling process. tracking. the hidden curriculum. aA teacher who believes (as a result of stereotypes based on the relationship between IQ and race) that some students of color are less capable of learning and treats them accordingly is an example of a self-fulfilling prophecy. (p. 350) According to Emile Durkheim,_____refers to those aspects of life that are extraordinary or supernatural. religion sacred profane superhuman bAccording to Emile Durkheim, sacred refers to those aspects of life that are extraordinary or supernatural. (p. 351) Three of the major world religions Christianity, Judaism, and Islam are characterized as: simple supernaturalism. animism. polytheism. monotheism. dThree of the major world religions Christianity, Judaism, and Islam are characterized as monotheism. (p. 352) According to the functionalist perspective, religion offers meaning for the human experience by: providing an explanation for events that create a profound sense of loss on both an individual and a group basis. offering people a reference group to help them define themselves. reinforcing existing social arrangements, especially the stratification system. encouraging the process of secularization. aAccording to the functionalist perspective, religion offers meaning for the human experience by providing an explanation for events that create a profound sense of loss on both an individual and a group basis. (p. 354) Celebrations on Memorial Day and the Fourth of July are examples of: religious tolerance. civil religion. patriotic ethnocentrism. separation of church and state. bCelebrations on Memorial Day and the Fourth of July are examples of civil religion. (p. 355) According to _____, the capitalist class uses religious ideology as a tool of domination. Emile Durkheim C. Wright Mills Karl Marx Max Weber cAccording to Karl Marx, the capitalist class uses religious ideology as a tool of domination. (p. 356) In regard to religion, Max Weber asserted that: church and state should be separated. religion could be a catalyst to produce social change. religion retards social change. the religious teachings of the Catholic church were directly related to the rise of capitalism. bIn regard to religion, Max Weber asserted that religion could be a catalyst to produce social change. (p. 356) "Her religion" and "his religion" have been examined from a(n) ____________ perspective. functionalist neo-Marxist conflict interactionist d"Her religion" and "his religion" have been examined from an interactionist perspective. (p. 357) The Anglican church in England and the Lutheran church in Sweden are examples of a(n): church. sect. denomination. ecclesia. dThe Anglican church in England and the Lutheran church in Sweden are examples of an ecclesia. (p. 358) In a_____membership largely is based on birth, and children of members typically are baptized as infants. church sect denomination cult aIn a church, membership largely is based on birth, and children of members typically are baptized as infants. (p. 358) According to the text, religious nationalism has led to the blending of strongly held religious and political beliefs is especially strong today in: the United States. Middle Eastern nations. Japan. Brazil. bAccording to the text, religious nationalism has led to the blending of strongly held religious and political beliefs is especially strong today in Middle Eastern nations. (p. 363) 15 Debates about the appropriate relationship between public education and religion have occurred only recently in the United States. FDebates about the appropriate relationship between public education and religion have occurred for many years. (p. 358) According to Emile Durkheim, teachers are the functional equivalent of priests in teaching students about morality. TNone(p. 340) Manifest functions in education include teaching specific subjects, such as science, history, and reading. TNone(p. 342) Meritocracy is the process of social selection in which class advantage and social status are linked to the possession of academic qualifications. FCredentialism is the process of social selection in which class advantage and social status are linked to the possession of academic qualifications. (p. 344) Through reading materials, classroom activities, and treatment by teachers and peers, female students learn that they are less important than male students. TNone(p. 345) Current supporters of a voucher system primarily want to provide central city students with additional educational options. FCurrent supporters of a voucher system primarily are members of affluent families and conservative religious groups who seek an alternative to public education and hope to use tax monies to subsidize their children's private school tuition. (p. 345) Tracking and ability grouping may produce resegregation at the classroom level. TNone(p. 347) The issue of IQ and race/ethnicity originated with the highly controversial book by Herrnstein and Murray. FThe issue of IQ and race/ethnicity first arose in regard to early-twentieth-century immigrants from Southern and Eastern Europe who scored lower, on average, on IQ tests than did Northern Europeans. (p. 350) Across cultures and in different eras, a wide variety of things have been considered sacred. TNone(p. 351) Secularization is the process by which religious beliefs, practices, and institutions lose their significance in sectors of society and culture. TNone(p. 354) According to functionalist theorists, religious teachings and practices help promote social cohesion by emphasizing shared symbolism. TNone(p. 355) Karl Marx wrote The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism to explain how religion may be used by the powerful to oppress the powerless. FMax Weber wrote The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism to explain how religion may be a catalyst for social change. (p. 356) Religious groups vary widely in their organizational structure. TNone(p. 358) Denominations tend to be more tolerant and less likely than churches to expel or excommunicate members. TNone(p. 358) "New-right" fundamentalists have encouraged secular humanism in the schools. F"New-right" fundamentalists have been especially critical of secular humanism in the schools. (p. 360)